A Knockout Performance: “I Play Rocky” Casting Director Rick Montgomery on Finding His Young Stallone

I Play Rocky (in limited theaters now, expands wide on November 20) tells the ultimate underdog story of how Sylvester Stallone fought to not only make Rocky (long before anyone knew it as an Oscar-winning hit) but star in the film as a complete unknown. So for casting director Rick Montgomery and director Peter Farrelly, it was only fitting to find a fresh face to play Stallone before he skyrocketed to worldwide fame.

The newcomer who met the challenge was Anthony Ippolito, who previously held small parts in Pixels as Adam Sandler’s son and The Offer, the Paramount+ series in which he portrayed a young Al Pacino on his way to The Godfather glory. I Play Rocky is the 27-year-old actor’s first leading role, and Montgomery says even Stallone (who had final approval on who played him in the movie) knew he was the right leading man when watching his unsolicited audition tape.

“It was love at first sight for me because I knew we had found our gold mine in Anthony; he looked like Stallone already, he had the mannerisms, personality, and his comedy down,” Montgomery recalls. “He understood the drama of the situation, when he really needed to push it and when he could pull back.” Once Ippolito was cast, he spent a year training and learning how to box, much as Stallone had to do in real life when preparing for Rocky in 1976.

(L to R) Kiki Seto as Talia Shire and Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo Credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Montgomery and Farrelly’s collaboration goes back decades, with work ranging from ’90s comedy classics like Dumb and Dumber and There’s Something About Mary to Oscar-winning dramas like Green Book, which nabbed Mahershala Ali a second Oscar.

“We all get better and wiser as we get older. That’s the one benefit of getting older: experience. I’m one of the few casting directors probably working in Hollywood today who works with the same director over and over again,” Montgomery says. “Peter has become my friend, mentor, collaborator and everything else. Our tastes are almost identical.”

Montgomery spoke with The Credits to break down Ippolito’s casting as Stallone and creating the ensemble around him to build out the world of Rocky, from strong, distinctive character actors like Tracy Letts to Matt Dillon to P.J. Byrne. This interview has been edited and condensed.

 

When you started the casting process to find a young Sylvester Stallone, was everyone on the same page about seeking out a new face?

Oh, definitely, very much so. I believe that Sylvester Stallone told Peter [Farrelly] that it would be great if we could find an unknown. In casting, you start off, and you’re looking at the world, you’re talking to everyone, and that’s where the process started for me. There really aren’t any celebrities that look like Stallone except Stallone. We knew we were going down that road, searching and searching. So that’s what made it exciting and challenging.

How long did the search take before you came across Anthony Ippolito?

I thought it was going to go on for quite a while because I had started almost a year before production, so I had spent about a month or so, maybe a few weeks more, sending out scripts, talking to agents, getting the word out, people reading the script. It’s a wonderful read. Then I got a call from Anthony’s agent who sent me Anthony’s tape. He had taken it on himself; he had gotten a script, read it thoroughly, figured it out, picked four scenes, and put them all on tape. The breadth and depth of that work was immense, so surprising and so real. It was never an impersonation. It was love at first sight for me because I knew we had found our gold mine in Anthony; he looked like Stallone already, he had the mannerisms, personality, and his comedy down. He understood the drama of the situation, when he really needed to push it and when he could pull back. Anthony made wonderful choices. Immediately, it was pretty obvious to all of us that he was our guy.

Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios.
Photo Credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

What scenes did he put on tape that stood out to you?

The scene between AnnaSophia Robb, who plays his first wife, Sasha Czack, and Anthony where they’re walking down the street; it’s early in their relationship, and he’s trying to talk to her. It really showed his personality; I was so knocked out by it because he’s funny and playful, all within the character of Stallone. I remember it very, very clearly. He also did the important “I Play Rocky” scene, where he’s talking to producers Robert Chartoff and Irwin Winkler about the importance of him playing that role. You have to understand — Anthony had already worked out his voice and how he was going to play it. It was shootable.

 

I know he played Al Pacino in The Offer, but the fact that he’s still largely a fresh face for people as a leading man adds a level of authenticity to the casting.

I think you’re right. It totally does because you’re not distracted by a star. You’re not thinking, “That’s so and so the star.” You’re looking at Anthony thinking, “That’s Stallone when he was 27, 28.” You really buy into it.

When you were hearing other people read for the part, was it hard for them to get past just doing the impersonation?

It’s very difficult. Just think about it — name any star, you have to find someone that looks like Brad Pitt who’s still living today and obviously still working today. This is Sylvester Stallone; he’s still working, and he has a successful TV show on right now with Tulsa King.

(L to R) Jay Duplass as John Avildsen, Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone and AnnaSophia Robb as Sasha Czack in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo Credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Did Sylvester Stallone have any involvement in the casting process?

He had approval over whoever we cast as Stallone. That’s what I was working toward and making sure I had the right fit. When Stallone saw him, he just instinctively knew this was the right guy.

How did you build out the cast around Anthony and the key figures in Rocky? While the film is a showcase for Anthony’s transformation, it’s also a true ensemble piece.

We put all the pieces together as Pete, and I always do — almost one by one. Once we had committed to Anthony and knew that was our guy, then I could start focusing on Sasha. At the same time, my staff and I were looking for the lookalikes for Talia Shire, Burgess Meredith, Carl Weathers. Apollo Creed was really a great story because I couldn’t find him. There were a lot of guys who were close, but finding the right age and the right everything [made it difficult]. Then I got a call from Stephan James’ manager who said, “Hey, did you think about Stephan James for this role?” And it’s like, “Yeah, I thought about it, but I just assumed it wasn’t a big enough role. He’s used to doing leads.” And he goes, “Oh no, we love this. He’s gonna love it.”

 

What about for Sasha?

We put a very short list together of four of our favorite actresses for Sasha and brought them in. We told the actors that if they’d like to read for the role, we’re happy to listen to them read, and I can give them sides—a scene or two—or they can just meet; we can look at their work and make a decision based on that. But AnnaSophia Robb really wanted the job. Her agent called me and said, “Hey, before we do this, can AnnaSophia give you a call? AnnaSophia wants to talk about the character and what she’s doing and just wants to kick it around with someone.” I offered that to all the women, of course; if they wanted to talk to me, feel free. My job is to have all these actors do the very best that they can. AnnaSophia put together this incredible reading; she had her accent down already. She looked very similar to Stallone’s first wife — not a spot on, but she was definitely within the ballpark. And we just kind of fell in love with her, just like you do in the movie. One of my favorite scenes is when she tells Anthony she’s pregnant.

(L to R) Toby Kebbell as Robert Chartoff, AnnaSophia Robb as Sasha Czack, P.J. Byrne as Irwin Winkler, Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone, and Jay Duplass as John Avildsen in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo Credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

And producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff, played by P.J. Byrne and Toby Kebbell?

Producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff are like the classic straight-man and funny-man dynamic. Without Toby, none of those scenes would have worked as strongly as they were. Their combination just works in such a big way; it was so much fun to try to cast against and bounce other characters off them.

 

And then you get Matt Dillon to play Frank Stallone Sr.

I wanted to get somebody that looked close to Stallone’s dad. Going through pictures and ideas, I came across Matt Dillon and thought, “Oh my gosh, this is perfect. If he’s available, I know Pete will want to cast him because he’s going to be good.” He was available, and sure enough, we were able to put him in the picture. You don’t recognize him at first. Did you recognize him at first?

I did not!

I love that. And Tracy Letts, that’s just what casting directors do for a living; we make lists, we create schedules for who might be right for this, and Tracy was our number one choice. We just felt he could add so much more to create a bigger character than it was on the page. Sandy was strong, but we knew that it needed a nuanced actor, somebody who could find the funny and erotic nature of it. He wasn’t just somebody who was angry and mad; he definitely found all those nuances and comedic beats that we end up laughing at. 

 

And of course, this is only the second year the Oscars have a dedicated casting category. Is this something you’ve seen as long overdue in your decades working in Hollywood? 

I’m obviously all for it and a supporter of all of this. It’s exciting that casting directors are now honored by Academy Award nominations, no question. If you can win an Academy Award, it’s certainly one of your crowning achievements. It’s long overdue, and major directors have been saying this for a long time. It all started with the old Hollywood system, where the studio actually cast the movies because of their stable of stars and the people they had in their stable. Then it became the director’s responsibility. It was Lynn Stalmaster who really changed it and brought it into its own. Now, with the number of actors that are out there, our responsibilities are so big that we even look coast to coast when we’re casting movies—Canada, Europe, wherever. I’m working on a film where I’m looking to England because there’s more of that type of actor that I’m looking for there than here in the States. The whole business has changed, and I think this is a very positive step forward.

Featured image: Anthony Ippolito stars as Sylvester Stallone in I PLAY ROCKY, from Amazon MGM Studios. Photo Credit: Claire Folger © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC. All Rights Reserved.

Tags
About the Author
Matt Minton

Matt Minton is a freelance journalist with bylines in Variety, The Progressive, The Credits, Us Weekly, and Next Best Picture. While completing a reporting internship at Variety, they honed in on covering international films, awards season, artisans, and LGBTQ+ trends in media. Matt is an Ithaca College graduate and voting member of GALECA, the Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics.